News and Announcements

When you pursue compensation in a lawsuit and finally win or settle your case, receiving your compensation can allow you to breathe a sigh of relief. However, there’s still the question of how much of that settlement you’ll actually get to keep—and how much will be lost to taxes. Whether you're receiving compensation for a personal injury, emotional distress, or other damages, it's crucial to understand how the IRS views these funds. Keep reading to learn more about the different types of lawsuit settlements and how they are taxed.

Understanding the Types of Settlements

Lawsuit settlements generally fall into two broad categories: compensatory and punitive. How these are taxed largely depends on the nature of the claim.

1. Compensatory Damages: Compensatory damages are meant to compensate you for a loss, harm, or injury. These can include medical expenses, lost wages, and other direct costs related to the injury or damage.
   1. Physical Injury or Illness: If your settlement is for a physical injury or illness, the IRS does not consider these amounts as taxable income. This means that the compensatory damages you receive for medical bills, pain and suffering, and lost wages due to physical injury are typically tax-free.
   2. Emotional Distress: Settlements for emotional distress or mental anguish are only tax-free if they are directly tied to a physical injury or illness. If the distress is unrelated to a physical injury, the settlement may be taxable, although you may be able to deduct medical expenses related to the emotional distress.
   3. Lost Wages: Lost wages due to a physical injury are generally tax-free, but if the lost wages are tied to a non-physical injury (like wrongful termination or discrimination), they are typically taxed as ordinary income.
2. Punitive Damages: Punitive damages, on the other hand, are intended to punish the defendant rather than compensate the plaintiff. The IRS considers punitive damages taxable, regardless of whether they are related to a physical injury or other claims. This means that if you receive punitive damages, you will likely owe taxes on that portion of your settlement.

Taxation of Interest on Settlement Amounts

In some cases, a settlement may include interest, particularly if there was a delay in receiving the payment. Interest earned on a settlement is always taxable, even if the underlying settlement is tax-free. For instance, if you receive interest on a personal injury settlement, that interest must be reported as income and will be subject to tax.

Allocation of Settlements

Settlement agreements often cover multiple types of damages. In these cases, the allocation of the settlement to different types of damages can significantly impact how much of the settlement is taxable.

• Structured Settlements: If your settlement is structured to be paid out over time, the tax implications could differ from a lump sum payment. Generally, each payment received is partially taxable depending on the allocation between taxable and non-taxable portions of the settlement.
• Apportioning the Settlement: Sometimes, the IRS may question how the settlement was divided between taxable and non-taxable categories. Proper documentation and careful allocation can help ensure that you don’t pay more taxes than necessary. It’s wise to consult with a tax professional when negotiating your settlement to minimize your tax burden.

Reporting Settlement Income

When it comes time to report your settlement on your tax return, it’s important to do so correctly. Misreporting can lead to penalties or additional taxes owed.

• Form 1099-MISC: In many cases, you will receive a Form 1099-MISC from the payer of the settlement, which reports the amount of the settlement that is taxable. Ensure that the amounts reported match your understanding of the taxable portion of your settlement.
• Tax Deductions: If you’re able to deduct certain legal fees or costs associated with obtaining the settlement, make sure to keep detailed records. The ability to deduct these fees depends on the nature of the settlement and your specific tax situation.

Legal Fees and Their Impact on Taxation

Legal fees can be a significant portion of a settlement, and how they are handled can affect your tax liability. If your attorney worked on a contingency fee basis, meaning they took a percentage of the settlement as their fee, you may still need to report the full amount of the settlement as income, including the portion paid to your attorney. In some cases, you can deduct the legal fees, but the rules around these deductions can be complex and are worth discussing with a tax professional.

State Tax Considerations

In addition to federal taxes, it’s important to consider how your state taxes lawsuit settlements. Some states may have different rules regarding the taxation of settlements, particularly for punitive damages and interest. Ensure you understand both federal and state tax obligations to avoid surprises.

Navigating the taxation of lawsuit settlements can be complex, but understanding the basics can help you plan for the tax implications and minimize your tax burden. Whether you’re dealing with compensatory damages, punitive damages, or interest, each component of your settlement may be taxed differently. Consulting with an experienced tax professional is essential to ensure you comply with IRS regulations and optimize your tax situation. If you have received or expect to receive a lawsuit settlement, contact Demian & Company CPAs today for help in understanding just how much of your compensation will be taxed.